So the latest thing “sweeping the blogosphere” is this, Mingle2.com gives an MPAA style rating to your blog based on certain words that occur in your blog. Here’s my rating:

Mingle2 – Free Online Dating
According to the site’s algorithm this is due to the following words and their occurances:
- death – 15 times
- murder – 3 times
- torture – twice
- zombie – once
I realize that most of these come from the Sun, May 20 post: Something Important. Where I quoted Joss Whedon’s Whedonesque.com post about Dua Kalil. And while that may be a mature subject I don’t believe anyone would consider the post overly graphic, and I’m sure no reasonable parent would feel the need to shield it from their 14-year old.
On The heels of Manhunt 2 being shelved because of its AO rating by the ESRB I find this just a bit ominous. Rating systems in this country have been largely ineffective at achieving their stated goal, that of keeping children away from dangerous content without censoring that content. AO rated games are almost unheard of, the only games with the ESRB’s highest rating are available for computers only (and there are only 23 of them). There are no AO rated games available for the largest segment of video gaming, console systems. Major retailers refuse to carry them, just as they refuse to carry NC-17 rated movies, and Sony, Nintendo and Microsoft refuse to grant license to any game with a rating higher than Mature. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas is a noted exception, but remember that its rating was changed from M to AO after the “hot coffee” modification was discovered, and copies of the game available now do not contain the mod and are labeled: second edition.
Anecdotally, many teens have seen R rated movies without their parent’s implicit consent. And this recent study from the Massachusetts General Hospital’s (MGH) Center for Mental Health and Media suggests that exposure to violent video games is extremely common among adolescent boys and girls alike. This seems to suggest that parents do not take M rated video games as seriously as R rated movies. Parents who are engaged with their children scrutinize the content that they are exposed to. All ratings are supposed to do is to provide a guide for parents in a media saturated environment. It should not be used to censor games, or movies or any media.
Check out the documentary This Film Is Not Yet Rated for an exposé of the MPAA ratings system.
I really hope that no one avoids this blog because it contains the words murder, torture and death. I think these topics have been dealt with in a sensible manner that is not inappropriate for children. And as for zombies: come on!
Recent Comments